| Team |
Player Picked |
Comment |
Studs Selected After |
| Anaheim |
Stanislav Chistov (5th, 2001) |
The ‘07 Cup win offers serious salve for the Stanislav screwup |
Mike Komisarek, Pascal Leclaire, R.J. Umberger, Ales Hemsky, Mike Cammalleri |
| Atlanta |
Patrick Stefan (no.1, 1999) |
The ‘99 harvest wasn’t swell to be sure, but this still is a serious stinker |
The Sedin twins, Martin Havlat |
| Boston |
Lars Jonsson (7th, 2000) |
A good recipe for Swedish meatballs would have delivered more |
Brooks Orpik, Alexander Frolov, Anton Volchenkov, Niklas Kronvall |
| Buffalo |
Shawn Anderson, (5th, 1986) |
This was a Shawn of the Dead selection |
Vincent Damphousse, Brian Leetch, Craig Janney, Teppo Numminen |
| Calgary |
Bryan Deasley (19th, 1987) |
The Flames’ no. 1 from ‘86, George Pelawa, died in a motorcycle crash that summer, making this a two-year strikeout stretch |
John LaClair, Eric Desjardins, Mathieu Schneider, Stephane Matteau |
| Carolina/Hartford |
Fred Arthur (8th, 1980) |
No relation to Bea Arthur, except in NHL impact |
Paul Coffey, Brent Sutter, Craig Ludwig, Steve Larmer, Andy Moog, Jari Kurri |
| Chicago |
Tony Tanti (12th, 1981) |
Wirtz maybe thought he’d sign cheap? |
Al MacInnis, Chris Chelios, Mike Vernon, John Vanbiesbrouck |
| Colorado/Quebec |
Aniel Dore (5th, 1988) |
Who doesn’t own an Aniel Dore Nordiques’ sweater? |
Jeremy Roenick, Teemu Selanne, Rob Blake, Rod Brind’Amour, Martin Gelinas |
| Columbus |
Alexander Picard (8th, 2004) |
Inspector Clousseau isn’t going to look into this pick — he made it |
Alexander Radulov, Drew Stafford, Andrej Meszaros, Wojtek Wolski |
| Dallas |
Jason Bacashihua (26th, 2001) |
Played with the ECHL’s Johnston Chiefs in ‘07-08, which for a first-rounder seven years after being drafted is a fairly moderate pace of development |
Derek Roy, Fedor Tyutin, Mike Cammalleri, Jason Pominville, Dave Steckel |
| Detroit |
Shawn Burr (7th, 1984) |
I thought briefly of exluding the Wings from this exercise, they draft so well, and you have to go back a bit to find a serious screwup |
Shane Corson, Sylvain Cote, Gary Roberts, Kevin Hatcher, Scott Mellanby |
| Edmonton |
Marc-Antoine Pouliot (22nd, 2003) |
Overlooked this scouting report by the rest of the league: “Thin, weak, won’t hit or backcheck or play in traffic. Other than that, he’s dandy.” |
Mike Richards, Corey Perry, Patrice Bergeron, Matt Carle |
| Florida |
Petr Taticek (9th, 2002) |
Why no postseasons in Sunrise, Cats’ fans ask? Look at this pick |
Alexander Semin, Chris Higgins, Alexander Steen, Cam Ward |
| Los Angeles |
Wally McBean (4th, 1987) |
Not a new lunch item at MickeyD’s |
Joe Sakic, Andrew Cassels, Mathieu Schneider, Luke Richardson |
| Minnesota (Wild/Stars) |
Brian Lawton (no. 1, 1983) |
The bridesmaid to Daigle |
Pat LaFontaine, Steve Yzerman, Tom Barrasso, Cam Neely |
| Montreal |
Terry Ryan (8th, 1995) |
Terry Hatcher would have looked better here |
Jarome Iginla, J.S. Giguere, Petr Sykora, Martin Biron |
| Nashville |
Brian Finley (6th, 1999) |
The day the music stopped in Honkeytonkville |
Barret Jackman, Martin Havlat, Mike Commodore, David Tanabe |
| New Jersey |
Adrian Foster (28th, 2001) |
Yo, Adrian! Legend has it that Foster wasn’t even on other teams’ lists — anywhere! |
Fedor Tyutin, Mike Cammalleri, Peter Budaj, Ray Emery, Patrick Sharp |
| NY Islanders |
Dave Chyzowski (2nd, 1989) |
Can’t blame Mad Mike for this one — he didn’t arrive until ‘95 |
Bill Guerin, Pavel Bure, Olaf Kolzig, Stu Barnes |
| NY Rangers |
Hugh Jessiman (12th, 2003) |
Hughe mistake! |
Brent Seabrook, Steve Bernier, Zach Parise, Ryan Getzlaf |
| Ottawa |
Alexander Daigle (no. 1, 1993) |
The Mother of all Misses; to “Daigle” in round one is every GM’s nightmare |
Chris Pronger, Paul Kariya, Todd Bertuzzi, Brendan Witt, Adam Deadmarsh |
| Philadelphia |
Claude Boivin (14th, 1988) |
Philly does real well in the first round; this year, not so much |
Rob Blake, Alexander Mogilny, Tony Amonte, Bret Hedican, Tie Domi |
| Phoenix |
Blake Wheeler ( 5th, 2004) |
Wheeler of misfortune; think Gretz & co. reached here? |
Rostislav Olesz, Alexander Radulov, Drew Stafford, Wojtek Wolski |
| Pittsburgh |
Zarley Zalapski (4th, 1980) |
ZZ FlopTop and agonizing alliteration |
Paul Coffey, Jari Kurri, Steve Larmer, Craig Ludwig, Brent Sutter |
| San Jose |
Pat Falloon (2nd, 1991) |
Plus, Pat had to don that original San Jose teal sweater on the ‘91 draft stage |
Scott Niedermayer, Peter Forsberg, Martin Lapointe, Brian Rolston, Alexei Kovalev |
| St. Louis |
Perry Turnbull (2nd, 1979) |
188 goals in an NHL career is nothing to snicker at, but methinks Ray Bourque would have helped out more |
Ray Bourque, Mike Gartner, Brian Propp, Kevin Lowe |
| Tampa |
Alexander Svitov (3rd, 2001) |
Tampa (Nikita Alexeev) hasn’t exactly struck Lightning with first-round Russians |
Pascal Leclaire, Alex Hemsky, R.J. Umberger, Shaone Morrisonn |
| Toronto |
Gary Nylund (3rd, 1982) |
This is the stuff of Cup droughts |
Scott Stevens, Phil Housley, Dave Andreychuk, Doug Gilmour |
| Vancouver |
Jere Gillis (4th, 1978) |
The Canucks have no home-grown Hall of Famers, including Gillis |
Mark Napier, Don Maloney, Doug Wilson, Bengt Gustafsson |
| Washington |
Greg Joly ( no.1, 1974) |
Good Golly what a stinker! “The next Bobby Orr” it was said of Joly in ‘74. Umm, not so much. |
Clark Gillies, Pierre Larouche, Bryan Trottier, Doug Riesbrough |