On Frozen Blog

A Haven for the Hockey Malnourished

The coldest days best warm my hockey heart


The 10 Worst Hockey Injuries of All Time


The recent and dramatic injuries suffered by Chris Clark and Jamie Heward led us to wonder what might be the 10 worst injuries suffered by NHLers, all time. This was no labor of the prurient or ghastly on our part, but rather a testament to the courage and guts elite hockey players regularly display, and the inherent dangers they face on every shift.

Tales of terror on the ice are legion, and can be culled from virtually every professional league as well as Europe, but we decided to restrict our survey to the NHL's.

Mark Howe suffered one of the worst injuries in hockey history on December 27, 1980. Late in the third period Howe crashed feet-first into the goal cage and basically impaled himself on a metal post at the center of the net. This injury led directly to the contemporary cage's redesign, which no longer features any exposed steel within. Howe was removed from the ice on a stretcher, treated in the hospital for a deep laceration to his left thigh and buttocks. The puncture narrowly missed the base of his spine, but he also could have bled to death.

Trent McCleary's career with Montreal ended prematurely on January 29, 2000, when he was struck in the throat by a slapshot from Philadelphia's Chris Therien while he fell to the ice attempting to block the shot. This recollection from pucksandbooks: "By coincidence I happened to be following this game on a bar TV, and I remember telling my date that night not to look at the television screen the moment this injury happened, knowing that a number of replays were to follow." The injury caused McCleary's throat to immediately collapse, making it difficult to breathe. Several surgeries were required before he could regain his speech. He never played again.

BallHype: hype it up!


Discussion

22 Comments on "The 10 Worst Hockey Injuries of All Time"

#1

user-pic

Posted by Victor, December 4, 2006 12:40 AM

As a follow-up to Peake's injury: I recall seeing a report (if I recall correctly, in the press notes handed out to the press corps before the game) a year or two ago with the news Peake's ankle was medically fused as nothing more could be done to try to give him normal use of his foot. I take that to mean his foot doesn't bend at that ankle.

Reply

#2

user-pic

Posted by Joe Pelletier, December 4, 2006 6:18 AM

love the article guys. Two more injuries deserve note - Steve Moore, because his career ended at the hands of another player, and Wayne Cashman in 1972. While Team Canada 72 was playing an exhibition game in Sweden while en route to Moscow, "Cash" was high sticked and needed 50 stitches in his tongue. Now that has to hurt!

Joe Pelletier
------------------
http://www.1972summitseries.com
http://www.legendsofhockey.blogspot.com

Reply

#3

user-pic

Posted by strungout, December 4, 2006 1:32 PM

Id think Kevin Stevens would be a fit in the top 10 for just the surgery alone...

http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/06173/700298-198.stm

"He had a concussion and cut over his right eye and needed nearly five hours of surgery to repair a fractured sinus bone and broken nose.

Because Stevens' injury happened in a game, we were able to watch it over and over in slow motion, and there was no secrecy about his subsequent care and recovery.

In fact, we almost got information overload with the description of his surgery, when doctors cut him ear to ear along the hairline, pulled back the skin, repaired the damage, then sewed his face back together."

Reply

#4

user-pic

Posted by pucksandbooks, December 4, 2006 2:08 PM

Kevin Stevens -- not so tough; he missed his shift while missing half his face. Hah. Seriously, all of these comments were illuminating and precisely of the sort we'd hope to invite. Thanks to all for sharing.

Reply

#5

user-pic

Posted by pepper, December 4, 2006 6:18 PM

Interesting, perhaps companion, piece from ESPN, following the Jiri Fischer scare last year.

http://sports.espn.go.com/nhl/news/story?id=2232738

Reply

#6

user-pic

Posted by sk84fun, December 4, 2006 6:50 PM

Interesting picks, but did you have to post that Malarchuk picture; I have seen that one enough times and lucky me, I was eating lunch while reading this thread.

Another one that comes to mind was the Pronger incident when he was hit with the puck during the playoff game between St Louis and Detroit.

Back to McCleary, he did try to play the next season, but retired a few weeks into training camp, when he realized that his reduced airway was preventing him from completing shifts at the level needed for the NHL. I know he before the lockout. Anybody know what he is doing now?

Reply

#7

user-pic

Posted by pucksandbooks, December 4, 2006 6:55 PM

sk8 -- when we discovered the Malarchuk image we all agreed on one thing: there was *no* way we were publishing it on the main page.

Reply

#8

user-pic

Posted by MNGopherGirl, December 4, 2006 6:59 PM

R.I.P. #19

Reply

#9

user-pic

Posted by exwhaler, December 4, 2006 7:14 PM

RE: picture

Yeah, thanks for that, but it was a nasty surprise when I opened up the entire article...

Reply

#10

user-pic

Posted by Netsrak, December 5, 2006 10:15 AM

Thank goodness my Web browser of choice (Opera) has a handy "Turn off all images" button so that I finish reading this entry without vomiting. Yeesh.

Reply

#11

user-pic

Posted by OrderedChaos, December 19, 2006 3:03 AM

Here's an interview with Jamie Heward by Mike Vogel, discussing his recent unfortunate tendency to get lots of stitches in his face:
http://www.washingtoncaps.com/news/news.asp?story_id=4421

Reply

#12

user-pic

Posted by VK, March 27, 2007 8:13 PM

I guess the all-star game in honour of Ace Bailey no longer keeps to the February tradition. It's interesting that it started as a result of an incident where a player was injured. Makes one wonder what the true appeal of the game is for many given the injuries that are occuring with more frequency, in particular those from fights such as Toronto's Newbury (still out of action) and Philly's Fedoruk (career is DONE, I think).

Reply

#13

user-pic

Posted by Galen, April 8, 2007 4:42 AM

wow... yeah that Clint Malarchuk thing. thats sick. haha, im a goalie and ill tell you this, after seeing that man. i didnt want to go to my game that was in an hour

Reply

#14

user-pic

Posted by Ferrari, September 20, 2007 10:58 PM

And these are only the pro injuries!

My husband has a hip full of metal from smashing knee first into the boards while playing pick-up hockey with friends; his femur punched a hole in the wing of his hip, ultimately shattering it into thousands of little fragments. Was told he'd never walk again.

He now wrestles professionally [not WWE, but he's got a following :) ].

Reply

#15

user-pic

Posted by allie, October 3, 2007 9:58 PM

this is an exiting blog, but there are way too many gruesome injuries to decide on the top 10. malarchucks incident is definately on my list, the picture really captures the significance of it! isnt this why goalies now have better protection around their neck? havent seen anything like that in years! but good list anyways!

Reply

#16

user-pic

Posted by Chris, October 28, 2007 12:52 AM

"it ultimately severed the relationship between a franschise player and his drafting organization"

Lindros wasn't drafted by the Flyers. He was a holdout from the Nordiques.

Reply

#17

user-pic

Posted by Jes Golbez, October 31, 2007 7:46 PM

One other injury that always freaked me out as Al MacInnis in his early career with the Flames.

Basically, he goes into the boards and ends up doing the splits... basically screwing up both sides of the groin...very painful to watch and think about

Reply

#18

user-pic

Posted by OMEGA, October 31, 2007 8:33 PM

The malarchuk incedent made me think twice about being a goalie. And I became one anyway(more protection)

Reply

#19

user-pic

Posted by Jason, February 5, 2008 6:24 AM

Here's a piece of NHL memorabilia... I know the guy who has the net Mark Howe impailed himself on. We're both from the Hartford area. He scored it when Aetna (insurance company that handled the accident claim) was clearing out some warehouse space. It's been sitting in my friends garage for about 18 years. I think he's looking to have someone take it off his hands. Talk about a conversation piece.

I miss my Whalers!

Reply

#20

user-pic

Posted by Miles, February 13, 2008 8:42 PM

I remember Ed Kea's injury in 1982 or so as prompting the helmet requirement.

Reply

#21

user-pic

Posted by viktor, August 9, 2008 12:06 AM

u forget about the swedish hockey player Bengt Åkerblom hwo died on ice during an exhibition game on October 15, 1995 between his team Mora IK and Brynäs IF, when his teammate was hit he flew up in the air and accidently cuted bengt åkerblom's coratid artery and his trachea, he died shortly after on Mora emergency.

btw, im sorry for my bad english :P

// viktor / Sweden

Reply

#22

user-pic

Posted by OrderedChaos (Mike Rucki), August 9, 2008 12:22 AM

Thank you for the comment Viktor -- and don't worry, your English is better than seen on most Internet message boards. :)

Reply

Leave a comment